Menu
Recently, we’ve received several questions regarding a new
product offering from The Scott’s Company called “Roundup for Lawns.” There are several versions of this product,
including both Northern
and Southern
grass options. The Northern grass
product, for use on Minnesota lawns, states that the product “kills weeds, not
the lawn.” Most of us are familiar with
the original version of Roundup, which contains the active ingredient
glyphosate, and we know that glyphosate is a non-selective vegetation killer-
meaning that it kills most plants that it is sprayed on. So, how does Roundup for Lawns not kill the
entire lawn?
The answer is simple; this product isn’t Roundup. In this case,
Scott’s is taking the liberty of using a widely known name of one of the most
effective herbicides, and putting something else in the bottle. So, what exactly is Roundup for Lawns? The Northern version of Roundup for lawns
contains the very well-known synthetic auxin herbicides MCPA and dicamba, as well
as quinclorac and sulfentrazone. You
will find some of these same active ingredients in other products because they
are so common. For example, Ortho
Weed B Gon Plus Crabgrass Control contains both quinclorac and dicamba, as
well as 2,4-D; in this product, dicamba and 2,4-D are the broadleaf weed
control products, and quinclorac provides the post-emergent control of
crabgrass. Bayer
Advance Weed Killer for Lawns contains only the synthetic auxin herbicides and will
not control crabgrass. Additionally, Bonide
Weed Beater Plus contains both quinclorac and dicamba, as well as 2,4-D. Sulfentrazone is added to Roundup for Lawns
because of its added benefit of controlling sedges, such as yellow nutsedge, in
addition to broadleaf weeds. And if you’re
looking for a product that is very similar to the formulation of Roundup for
Lawns, you can find that in the PBI Gordon product called Surge,
although this does not contain quinclorac.
Some points to note.
1) if you plan to use Roundup for Lawns on your lawn, be sure you do not
mistake this for a bottle of Roundup containing glyphosate, which will kill
your lawn; 2) Roundup is an emotional topic for many, but just because this
bottle says Roundup, it is not Roundup as we think of it; in fact, the
herbicide active ingredients in Roundup for Lawns are regarded as more toxic
than glyphosate (see: Toxicity
of Pesticides); 3) if you’re looking for a good broad-spectrum
post-emergent weed control product, Roundup for Lawns will work fine for you;
4) be sure to follow all label instructions when using this product, including
proper personal protective equipment, application strategies, and re-entry
intervals.
Sam, Great post, we were wondering about that and our customers were wondering.
ReplyDeleteWell, no it will not work "well" for anyone, at least not in the delivery system I got with mine. "Just hook it to the hose", right? Wrong, if you do that, how can you know how much product you are dispensing? The bottle is opaque, can't see the fall of fluid as you spray, so how can you possibly put, say 6.4 ounces per 1000 sq/feet? And you can't even take the lid off, and dispense into a proper dispenser with gradations you can see. I guess you are supposed to saw off the top and pour it into a translucent dispenser, not included of course. Brilliant
ReplyDeleteHow harmful is this mixture for dogs that might injest grass? A normal lawn service needs to post signs does this?
ReplyDeleteJmichael Isbell, your comments are inconsistent with the product's application instructions.
ReplyDeleteDo you know why this product is not available in New York State?
ReplyDeleteWhile Dicamba isn't quite as volatile as 24D, it cans still easily damage tomatoes, peppers and ornamental from a great distance.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the best way to get rid of creeping charlie
ReplyDeleteWhat is the best way to get rid of creeping charlie
ReplyDeleteThank you very much for your post.
ReplyDeleteThis is the only product I have found to kill creeping Charlie, besides regular roundup. Expensive product but works extremely well on all weeds
ReplyDeleteOnly product that I have found that kills creeping charlie, besides regular roundup. Works extremely well on all weeds. Little expensive but worth it.
ReplyDeleteI used Round Up for lawns concentrate and it killed my lawn. Followed directions by mixing 4 oz per gallon and applied later in the day at 82' and 2 days later notice dead spots everywhere I sprayed. Very upsetting!
ReplyDeleteI used round of for lawns and it killed my lawn. Follow directions by mixing 4 oz per gallon and applied later in the day at 82' and 2 days later notice dead spots everywhere I sprayed.
ReplyDelete